The most common DOB violations on NYC construction and facade jobs: 36 months of data
We counted every DOB violation returnable to OATH — the ECB violations on NYC Open Data — issued from November 1, 2023 to October 31, 2026, and kept the 97,735 that concern construction and facade work. The ten most common, what sets each one off in the field, its penalty in the current schedule, and a checklist for the super before the inspector comes.
Last checked: Nov 9, 2026
Key facts
- Counted 97,735 of the 169,012 DOB ECB violations issued November 1, 2023 to October 31, 2026, 19,921 of them in Manhattan (NYC Open Data 6bgk-3dad)
- Top three work without a permit 20,559 · unsafe site conditions (BC Chapter 33) 17,926 · a correction not certified or an order not obeyed 15,209
- Trend 28,191, then 32,578, then 36,966 a year citywide; Manhattan 6,922, 6,115, 6,884
- Class 1 38% immediately hazardous: no cure, correct at once
- Outcome 28% of the decided summonses ended in default, at the schedule’s higher default penalty (1 RCNY §102-01)
What are the most common DOB violations on construction and facade jobs?
From November 1, 2023 to October 31, 2026, the three most common were work without a permit (AC §28-105.1: 20,559 summonses), unsafe site conditions under Building Code Chapter 33 — scaffolds, debris, unprotected edges, stored material, missing safeguards (17,926) — and, after an earlier violation, a correction never certified or a Commissioner’s order not obeyed (AC §28-204.4 and §28-201.1: 15,209). Facade conditions come next: 6,857 failure-to-maintain summonses whose inspector named a facade element, and 4,909 for exterior walls (AC §28-302.1). Then site documents and signs, sheds and other temporary structures on an expired or missing permit, work that departs from the approved plans, shed and pedestrian-protection defects, and FISP filings.
Key considerations
How we counted
The source is DOB’s ECB violations on NYC Open Data (6bgk-3dad): every violation returnable to OATH, counted by its issue date and its first charge — 6,212 of the 169,012 issued in the window carry a second one. We kept the 97,735 about construction sites, permits, plans, sheds, scaffolds, fences and facades (19,921 in Manhattan) and left out 71,277 about the building’s other systems and its use: interior and building-systems maintenance (18,259), elevators (11,618), occupancy and illegal conversions (10,597), egress and fire protection (6,679), electrical (6,109), boilers (4,835), zoning (4,722), signs, plumbing and gas, cranes and derricks, and miscellaneous charges whose inspector text is not about a construction site. Penalties are the amounts of the 1 RCNY §102-01 penalty schedule as DOB publishes it today: the standard penalty, and the higher one on default.
Work without a permit (AC §28-105.1)
20,559 summonses, 2,054 in Manhattan, 9,687 of them Class 1. It is written when work that needs a permit goes on with none on file — anything beyond ordinary repair, or a demolition (ordinary repair or work permit). Schedule: Class 1 $2,500, $12,500 on default; Class 2 $1,250, $6,250 on default; Class 3 $250, $500 on default. Class 2 and Class 3 can be cured; Class 1 cannot. Decided at a hearing, the median penalty imposed was the standard amount: $2,500 for Class 1 and $1,250 for Class 2.
Unsafe site conditions (BC Chapter 33)
17,926 summonses, 3,265 in Manhattan. The largest group, 8,926, is DOB’s miscellaneous Chapter 33 charge; in its inspectors’ descriptions a scaffold is named 2,149 times, debris or netting 1,391, the sidewalk or walkway 1,377, guardrails, open edges or holes 1,167, and stored material 1,062. Failure to safeguard the public and property (BC 3301.2) adds 3,030 and housekeeping (BC 3303.4) 2,382. Schedule: miscellaneous Chapter 33, Class 1 $5,000 and Class 2 $2,500, $10,000 on default; BC 3301.2, Class 1 $10,000 ($25,000 on default) and Class 2 $5,000 ($10,000). Neither can be cured.
A correction not certified, an order not obeyed (AC §28-204.4, §28-201.1)
15,209 summonses, 3,391 in Manhattan, and rising: 3,349, 4,204, then 7,656 a year. Most of them, 10,489, are AC §28-204.4: a violation came with the Commissioner’s order to correct it and file a Certificate of Correction, and none was filed. Schedule: Class 2, $1,250, $6,250 on default, no cure. Failing to comply with a Commissioner’s order (AC §28-201.1, 4,434) is Class 1: $2,500, $12,500 on default. DOB’s own violations (3h2n-5cm9) add 5,675 «fail to certify Class 1» (AEUHAZ1) in the same window. How a correction is certified: DOB violations and OATH hearings.
Facade conditions (AC §28-302.1, §28-301.1)
Exterior walls not maintained (AC §28-302.1): 4,909 summonses, 1,376 in Manhattan, 2,626 of them Class 1. The general failure to maintain the building (AC §28-301.1) brought 24,380 more, and in 6,857 of them the inspector’s description names the facade or an exterior element — brick, parapet, cornice, lintel, coping, terra cotta, masonry, a fire escape, a balcony, spalling, stucco, a chimney, a shelf angle or a window sill. Schedule: §28-302.1, Class 1 $5,000 ($25,000 on default), Class 2 $2,500 ($10,000), Class 3 $500; §28-301.1, Class 1 $2,500 ($12,500), Class 2 $1,250 ($6,250), Class 3 $500. In the OATH records the amount charged on most Class 1 summonses rose from February 2025: $1,250 to $2,500 under §28-301.1, $2,500 to $5,000 under §28-302.1. What each facade classification commits the owner to: Safe, SWARMP or Unsafe.
Sheds, scaffolds and fences: the permit and the specs
Temporary structures with no valid permit: 4,934 summonses, 1,121 in Manhattan; 3,782 of them are a shed or other temporary construction equipment left up on an expired permit (BC 105.8.2): Class 2, $1,250, $6,250 on default, curable. Shed and pedestrian protection: 4,320, 1,574 in Manhattan — 3,569 for protection that does not meet code specifications (BC 3307.1: Class 2, $2,400, $10,000 on default) and 214 for no shed where one is required (BC 3307.6.2: Class 1, $10,000, $25,000 on default). The construction fence (BC 3307.7): 2,767, Class 2, $1,000, $5,000 on default. No sidewalk shed milestone penalty appears in DOB’s safety violations (855j-jady) through October 31, 2026; those penalties are in sidewalk shed permits, and the permits in shed renewal, supported scaffolds and suspended scaffolds.
Site documents, signs and the posted permit
5,135 summonses, 1,226 in Manhattan: the documents BC Chapter 33 requires on site, missing or not displayed (BC 3301.7: 2,719; Class 1 $2,500 and Class 2 $1,250, no cure), the project information panel, shed parapet panel or construction sign (BC 3301.9: 1,442; Class 2, $1,250), the permit not posted (AC §28-105.11: 716; Class 2, $300, $1,500 on default, curable) and the approved plans not on site (AC §28-104.2.2: 175).
Work that departs from the approved plans (AC §28-105.12.2)
4,728 summonses, 1,312 in Manhattan. Schedule: Class 1 $2,500 ($12,500 on default), Class 2 $1,250 ($6,250), Class 3 $500. The cure works here: 1,528 of the 3,220 Class 2 summonses ended cured — corrected and certified by the cure date; their median penalty was $0.
FISP filings (AC §28-302.4, §28-302.5)
3,634 summonses, 1,826 of them in Manhattan: a facade report not submitted (§28-302.4: 1,754; Class 2, $2,500, $10,000 on default), no acceptable amended report showing the unsafe conditions corrected (§28-302.5: 1,361; Class 2, $1,250, $6,250 on default) and no measures to secure public safety at an unsafe facade (§28-302.5: 415; Class 1, $10,000, $25,000 on default). DOB’s safety violations (855j-jady) add 3,721 FISP violations in the window, of five types: FISPNRF, no report or a late filing (1,627); FISPHAZ, a hazardous condition (724); FTC-FC-UNSAFE (697); FISPFCS, SWARMP conditions not corrected (550); and FTC-FC-SWARMP (123). The FISP filing penalties are in FISP Cycle 10.
Working under a Stop Work Order (AC §28-207.2.2)
1,985 summonses: 1,558 for continuing work while a Stop Work Order was in place and 427 for tampering with, removing or defacing the posted order (AC §28-207.2.5). On the summons for continuing work, the schedule sets Class 1, $10,000, $25,000 on default; in the OATH records the amount charged rose from $5,000 on summonses from February 25, 2025. The order itself, how it is lifted and the Administrative Code’s own penalty: Stop Work Orders.
The ten most common, year by year
DOB ECB violations (NYC Open Data 6bgk-3dad), first charge, issue dates November 1, 2023 to October 31, 2026. Row 4 counts the §28-301.1 summonses whose inspector description names a facade element.
| Violation | Section | 36 months | Manhattan | Nov 2023 – Oct 2024 | Nov 2024 – Oct 2025 | Nov 2025 – Oct 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Work without a permit | AC §28-105.1 | 20,559 | 2,054 | 5,377 | 7,899 | 7,283 |
| Unsafe site conditions | BC Chapter 33 | 17,926 | 3,265 | 5,018 | 6,095 | 6,813 |
| Correction not certified, order not obeyed | AC §28-204.4, §28-201.1 | 15,209 | 3,391 | 3,349 | 4,204 | 7,656 |
| Failure to maintain: a facade element named | AC §28-301.1 | 6,857 | 1,323 | 1,784 | 2,267 | 2,806 |
| Site documents, signs, posted permit | BC 3301.7, BC 3301.9, AC §28-105.11 | 5,135 | 1,226 | 1,547 | 1,786 | 1,802 |
| Temporary structure without a valid permit | BC 105.8.2 | 4,934 | 1,121 | 1,655 | 1,441 | 1,838 |
| Exterior walls not maintained | AC §28-302.1 | 4,909 | 1,376 | 2,060 | 1,685 | 1,164 |
| Work not per the approved plans | AC §28-105.12.2 | 4,728 | 1,312 | 1,370 | 1,566 | 1,792 |
| Shed and pedestrian protection | BC 3307 | 4,320 | 1,574 | 1,407 | 1,383 | 1,530 |
| FISP filings and unsafe facades | AC §28-302.4, §28-302.5 | 3,634 | 1,826 | 2,022 | 970 | 642 |
Checklist: before the inspector comes
- Every scope of work has its permit, in force and posted at the site — the shed, scaffold and fence included.
- The shed, scaffold and fence permit expiration dates are on the schedule, and each is renewed before it lapses.
- The approved plans and their amendments are on site, and the work matches them.
- The documents BC Chapter 33 requires are on site, and the project information panel and construction signs are up.
- Edges and openings are protected — guardrails, toe boards, covered holes — and debris netting is in place.
- No loose debris: material is stacked and secured, away from edges and off the walkway.
- The shed and the fence meet their specifications, nothing unlawful is posted on them, and the adjoining property is protected.
- A loose facade condition is made safe at once, and FISP reports and amended reports go in on time.
- Every earlier violation has an approved Certificate of Correction, and no work goes on under a Stop Work Order.
Sources
- NYC Open Data, “DOB ECB Violations” (6bgk-3dad)
- NYC Open Data, “DOB Safety Violations” (855j-jady)
- NYC Open Data, “DOB Violations” (3h2n-5cm9)
- NYC Open Data, “OATH Hearings Division Case Status” (jz4z-kudi)
- 1 RCNY §102-01: Buildings Penalty Schedule (classes, cure, stipulation, mitigation, default)
- NYC DOB, Certificate of Correction (DOB NOW: Safety; AEUHAZ)
Checked against the official text on November 9, 2026.
Related guides
- DOB violations and OATH hearings in NYC: cure, stipulate, pay or fightA cure by the date on the summons means no hearing and no penalty; a stipulation gives 75 days and about half the penalty; a default can reach $25,000. Paying does not close a violation — an approved Certificate of Correction in DOB NOW: Safety does.
- Stop Work Orders in NYC: full or partial, and how to get one liftedA full order stops all work except what makes the site safe; a partial one stops part of it. Working against an order costs $6,000, then $12,000 each time. The steps DOB lists to lift it, and the conditions that most often cause one.
- Sidewalk shed permits in NYC: when one is required, and the 90-day ruleA shed is required for facade work more than 40 ft above curb level and whenever a dangerous condition exists. Since February 2026, permits last 90 days, renewals require an RDP progress report, and stalled sheds carry penalties that DOB expects to start imposing in early 2027.